Sunday, November 15, 2009

MPH's Two-Way Tie and Other Stories

I guess most of you had forgotten all about the MPH-Alliance Short Story Competition. After all, the shortlist was revealed way back in July.

Well, the prize-giving was held on Saturday at Subang Parade, and I guess that everyone was surprised because it was a two-way tie between Booker-longlisted author Tan Twan Eng and complete newcomer, Ivan Yeo Mun Kit.

I was one of the six judges for the competition, and let me tell you that there was plenty of lively debate about all the shortlisted stories - but the panel was completely split over which one should win outright, hence the compromise. The sponsors were kind enough to donate one more top of the range laptop, and the prize-money was shared.


Left to right above : Ivan, Twan Eng's mum - Sally Tan, guest Mano Maniam who gave a very good speech on the importance of stories, Datuk Dr. Abdullah b Abdul Rahman, Director of the MPH Group of Companies, runner-up Shih-Li Kow, Zed Adams father (?), and Lee Eeleen. The other runner up, Vincent Foo Hiap Khian, could not attend the event - he lives in Sarawak and we were told that he is over-70. (So -hurray - it isn't just about young writers making a fiction debut.)

Tan Twan Eng's Some Things Will Remain is a heart-stopping drama in which a woman is forced into murder to keep her child, and its terrible climax contrasts sharply with the traquility and beauty of the setting. It asks important questions too about whether such a killing can ever be justified, and whether a person is ever truly able to make amends.

Ivan Yeo Mun Kit is a writer I am sure we will be hearing much more from in future after this promising start. All the judges loved the humour and the carefully observed detail in this story of a young man learning to drive and juggling the relationship with his “not girlfriend”. Ivan has a strong voice and has a great ear for dialogue. His characters were very well drawn. There was some disagreement among the judges about whether we liked the ending though. (But then disagreement is what makes the whole process interesting!)

I won't say any more here about the other stories beyond that I hope these writers will be encouraged to keep writing. (And I hope that others who didn't make the shortlist won't despair, there were some excellent near-misses, and other writers who show a lot of promise.)


The prize for the Teen category which went to the best story on the theme of Staying and Leaving went to Emily Jong. Again, congrats to all prize winners and I hope we are hearing more about you all soon.

It was nice to reconnect with friends at the event. Below is Shih-Li Kow who came with her son Jack, talking to Lim Soon Heng who was one of the judges of the teen prize. I also enjoyed meeting the members of Electric Minds Project, who put on an entertaining and well-acted sketch for us.


The biggest congrats of the day I think must go to MPH for organising this very much needed competition to give local writers something concrete to aim for, and to Alliance Bank for supporting it. I do hope it returns next year!

9 comments:

Zed Adam said...

Yeah Sharon, that's my dad and his yellow trainers, heh. I'm on extended stay in Labuan, I couldn't make it. And congratulations to the winners!

:)

Amir Muhammad said...

Just curious: were the judges aware of the writers' identities during the deliberation of the final 6?

Fadz said...

Congratulations to the winners!

Sorry I missed the prize-giving ceremony. Didn't get an invite :(. A friend of mine got the invite though.

bibliobibuli said...

Zed - was sorry i didn't get a chance to say hi to your dad. congrats to you again and get working on a novella based on this story ... then Amir can make a film of it. (the tiger on the plate scene would rival any scene from "susuk")

No Amir. all the judging was blind. which was interesting. i could have sworn that i heard Eeleen's voice in one of the other stories which turned out to be Ridzwan Othman's! i was gobsmacked when i hadn't identified Shih-li's story as hers. wasn't surprised by twan eng's identity because of the "bigness" of story and theme.

my only regret is that the judges only saw 20 pre-selected stories of the 400 or so submitted.

Fadz - not sure if it was an invite only do - it was held in a very open concourse and i'm sure you could have slipped in to listen.

Amir Muhammad said...

Shih-Li is a chameleon, she can change styles at will! Even Pang & Jerome (who work for her at Central Market) didn't identify her 'Body 2 Body' story as hers when it was chosen blind.

bibliobibuli said...

i think Shih-Li is experimenting which is really nice to see. you need to be playful as a way of learning - just as you try on new fashions to see what suits you.

Damyanti said...

I've been a fan of Shih-Li's writing from the first time she wrote in News from home. Can't wait for her next book.

Amir Muhammad said...

When will the book of winning stories be out??

bibliobibuli said...

I don't know but hope it won't be long ...